Bad rap for cassettes?

Discussion in 'Pro Audio' started by Rob Adelman, Aug 10, 2003.

  1. Rob Adelman

    Rob Adelman Guest

    I know many here sneer at them. The other day at Walmart I saw a 5 pack
    of Maxell XLII tapes for about 6 bucks. (Do they still make the XLIIS?)

    So I just recorded Abraxas and DSOTM off of SACD's onto these cassettes
    and I am listening to them on my 20 year old Sony walkman. Even through
    this crude chain I would listen this way over CD's all day long.

    Rob Adelman, Aug 10, 2003
    1. Advertisements

  2. Do you consider yourself to have a good sense of pitch?

    My major complaint with the Philips cassette format is its poor wow-and-
    flutter performance that drives me nuts because I am continually aware of
    the pitch variations! Add the format's unit-to-unit absolute speed issues,
    and I don't understand how anyone with an even moderate pitch sense can
    prefer cassettes over CD's!
    Michael R. Kesti, Aug 10, 2003
    1. Advertisements

  3. Rob Adelman

    Rob Adelman Guest

    Yes, I can tell if it is off. The walkman plays back slightly from my
    recording deck (Denon) and of course when the batteries are getting low
    it doesn't sound so good. The car players usually seem to be pretty
    close. But it sounds less harsh. I can turn it up and listen for hours
    without the fatigue I get from CD's.
    Rob Adelman, Aug 10, 2003
  4. Rob Adelman

    Arny Krueger Guest

    Given the choice of available opportunities, a fast CD rip onto my NJB3 as a
    wav file would hit the spot. Sounds like an idea! I think I'll do it right
    after I push "Send".
    To say the least. Or a sense of noise, or a sense of FM distortion, or a
    sense of gratuitous dynamics corruption. Furthermore, the only thing worse
    than how cassettes sound is how they measure.

    IME & IMO cassette never sonically measured up to LP. My opinion of LP
    playback is neither much of a secret nor could it possibly get much worse.
    Arny Krueger, Aug 10, 2003
  5. Rob Adelman

    Stephen Sank Guest

    If you own a Nakamichi Dragon or Revox B215/A721, with quartz locked capstan
    servos & 0.015% or less wow/flutter, then you'll get along with cassettes
    just fine, even if you have the ultimate perfect pitch.

    Stephen Sank, Owner & Ribbon Mic Restorer
    Talking Dog Transducer Company
    5517 Carmelita Drive N.E.
    Albuquerque, New Mexico [87111]
    Auth. Nakamichi & McIntosh servicer
    Payments preferred through
    Stephen Sank, Aug 10, 2003
  6. Rob Adelman

    Mike Guest

    Hey that analog compression from tape saturation sounds good period.
    Thats the way it is.

    Mike, Aug 10, 2003
  7. Ah, thanks for that information- I now know I need never waste time reading
    your ill-informed posts ever again.

    I'm reminded of an LP connoisseur who likened the listening experience
    (complete with surface noise) to that of drinking Grange Hermitage- would
    you forgo that sublime experience because there was sediment at the bottom?

    (Arny to wine waiter- "send this rubbish back, there's dirt in the bottom!")
    Kieran McCoey, Aug 11, 2003
  8. Rob Adelman

    Arny Krueger Guest

    How did they avoid tape slip?
    Arny Krueger, Aug 11, 2003
  9. How does owning an overpriced, although very nice, deck allow me to play
    them with this accuracy in my car or anywhere away from my home? How does
    it help playback tapes recorded anywhere other than in such a deck?

    Since I began using digital media, I find that cassettes suck. YMMV.

    As for Rob's CD listening fatigue, I feel that the strident high end that
    probably causes this is the result of poor production rather than a fault
    in the medium.
    Michael R. Kesti, Aug 11, 2003
  10. Rob Adelman

    Mike Guest

    The only really good advantage of perfect pitch is tuning a piano. After
    it is right up there with having tinnitus. The whole idea of music is the
    relation of notes to each other. Otherwise we wouldn't have keys or
    numbers of intervals in different cultures (i.e. there have been systems
    with as
    many as 24 intervals in an octave).

    You go up to a higher octave and your ear has to hear the ratio relationship
    notes to hear them as the same not an octave up. Another relative

    Mike, Aug 11, 2003
  11. I couldn't agree more, Rob. IMO, CD's, unlike cassettes, are capable of
    good sound.
    Michael R. Kesti, Aug 11, 2003
  12. Rob Adelman

    Stephen Sank Guest

    Evidently, you have never owned a high-end Nakamichi or Revox cassette deck.

    Stephen Sank, Owner & Ribbon Mic Restorer
    Talking Dog Transducer Company
    5517 Carmelita Drive N.E.
    Albuquerque, New Mexico [87111]
    Auth. Nakamichi & McIntosh servicer
    Payments preferred through
    Stephen Sank, Aug 11, 2003
  13. Rob Adelman

    Arny Krueger Guest

    The CD format is capable of subjectively facsimile reproduction, and
    delivers it quite consistently. I can't imagine any reasonable listener
    having trouble detecting the sonic impact of a single generation of cassette

    I think that just about everybody knows that the cassette format is
    congenitally colored. A more probable interpretation of "cassettes sound
    better than CDs" would be that it's been a slow weekend and someone wants to
    try to make the Usenet juices run. Hey, if it worked for Mark Levinson, it
    might work for them!
    Arny Krueger, Aug 11, 2003
  14. Rob Adelman

    Arny Krueger Guest

    As it has been for decades, it really depends on the music itself. There's
    quite a bit of latitude for the original source format.

    In this day and age there's nothing magical about direct mic feeds. Good
    digital transcriptions of them are readily available, and not that hard to
    That hasn't been my experience. But, here's a great opportunity for
    interminable arm-wrestling about what constitutes a *good* cassette deck.


    I'd like to see (and listen to) two .wav files in any common format from
    16/44 to 24/192, one of being the original source, and one of which has been
    round-tripped through the cassette machine of anybody's choice.

    Let's see if they can be distinguished via a PCABX test. I'll bet they can!

    One little hook - most of the program material is up to anybody to choose,
    but it has to include every *reference* .wav file posted at
    The compendium I contributed to the last RAP CD suffices.
    Poke as you will Sommerwerck, it doesn't change reality.

    Reality is that for the more subtle differences, trained listeners can
    listen to the wrong music for a year and get nowhere, and listen to the
    right music for 10 seconds and wrap it up.

    The *magic* of long term listening tests has been pretty thoroughly
    deconstructed. It's like the benefits of talking to plants, every time
    someone tries to pin it down, it's suddenly not there.

    What long term listening IS good for is finding the *right* 10 or less
    seconds of music that makes the difference clear, if such a thing is
    possible. With loops through cassette land, it's always possible if the
    music is reasonably challenging, and mostly even if it isn't.

    However, if you loop some music through a cassette machine to make your
    reference tracks, then it might be pretty hard to hear the next generation
    of degradation. That's not really fair play, right?
    Arny Krueger, Aug 11, 2003
  15. Rob Adelman

    Scott Dorsey Guest

    Mine do.
    Scott Dorsey, Aug 11, 2003
  16. You should be ducking your head after such an outdated opinion about cubic
    inches in engines being the primary performance spec. I've brought it up
    before, but there are easily 4 cylinder Hondas out there producing 700 hp
    with 2000 cc engines. Hell, crate Chevy engines only run about 330 hp for a
    350 HO Chevy, and that's certainly over 5 liters (60.2 CI per liter, I
    believe). So we're talking a 700 hp engine with 2 liters vs a 5+ liter
    engine at only 330? Sometimes size doesn't matter! <g>

    The point being that there's always an exception that proves the rule, which
    I never understood while I was growing up. Either it fits, or it don't fit.
    If it's not true one hundred percent of the time, then it's not true. But
    American know-how and production capabilities somehow made this statement a

    Cubic inches don't make horsepower, and tape, in and of itself, doesn't make
    sound quality. I offer a couple of George Massenberg produced Lil' Feat
    albums on cassette that will knock your socks off as "the exception" (not
    ANYTHING reproduced by Bill Payne and Paul Barerre).

    However, I'm only offering up exceptions as the proof that a generalized
    statement doesn't work. Tape merely sounds like it sounds. It's up to the
    individual to enjoy the content, and when one tries to put sound quality
    above the content, they've lost their advantage. A little $25k Subaru WRX
    with a 3 liter engine runs the quarter at 5 seconds off the showroom floor.
    A $60k Corvette runs the quarter at 5 seconds. Apples and oranges, Arny.
    Which one's the apple and which one's the orange?


    Roger W. Norman
    SirMusic Studio
    Purchase your copy of the Fifth of RAP CD set at See
    how far $25 really goes.
    Roger W. Norman, Aug 11, 2003
  17. Rob Adelman

    Mike Guest

    I use to learn songs on guitar from what was within my head. Not
    sitting down listening to the record. A lot of times I didn't have the
    record. I would find out later that I had learned them quite closely
    except I had learned them in a different key than the original. Really
    relative pitch on my part.

    Mike, Aug 12, 2003
  18. Rob Adelman


    Aug 9, 2017
    Likes Received:

    They are back boys.
    Roxbrough, Aug 10, 2017
    1. Advertisements

Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments (here). After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.