- Joined
- Aug 30, 2005
- Messages
- 2,309
- Reaction score
- 0
Markus,
I can't tell the size of that WE - there's nothing to compare it to is there?
No I've never heard Guy's system, only heard about it second hand. The cabinet of Kevin's prototype seems to be based on the Oracle as is Guy's I believe. I hope to hear Guy's at some point in the future - I imagine it's outstanding.
I hear more midrange colouration on both the Altec and Vitavox than I do with the JBL or TAD modern equivalents. I personally seem to be more susceptable to this colouration than some listeners - in the same way that other listeners don't get on with Metal dome tweeters or SACD.
I feel modern drivers and horns have many characteristics that have more in common with electrostatics than vintage drivers like the S2. IMO it's a bit like the differences between a typical SET sound and say a Berning or Hovland. I have long had a love affair with panels so I suppose it's natural for me to be drawn to speakers that offer similar qualities along with greater dynamics and bandwidth.
Lovers of SET's and Vitavox might well find a TAD 4003 to sound a little cool and unemotional. Having said that, I personally would love to hear something like an Ongaku powering a modern horn based system. I'm not including Avant Garde in this as to my ears they sound somewhat different and not as open as the JBL and TAD's I have heard.
Don't get me wrong though. I'd still bite Kevin's arm off for those prototypes - It's an emotional experience to listen to a system of such quality and it's the best I have heard this year by a country mile. I just think I might personally prefer them with a 4003 or 476be in place of the S2 and an ET 703 in place of the 2405.
I can't tell the size of that WE - there's nothing to compare it to is there?
No I've never heard Guy's system, only heard about it second hand. The cabinet of Kevin's prototype seems to be based on the Oracle as is Guy's I believe. I hope to hear Guy's at some point in the future - I imagine it's outstanding.
I hear more midrange colouration on both the Altec and Vitavox than I do with the JBL or TAD modern equivalents. I personally seem to be more susceptable to this colouration than some listeners - in the same way that other listeners don't get on with Metal dome tweeters or SACD.
I feel modern drivers and horns have many characteristics that have more in common with electrostatics than vintage drivers like the S2. IMO it's a bit like the differences between a typical SET sound and say a Berning or Hovland. I have long had a love affair with panels so I suppose it's natural for me to be drawn to speakers that offer similar qualities along with greater dynamics and bandwidth.
Lovers of SET's and Vitavox might well find a TAD 4003 to sound a little cool and unemotional. Having said that, I personally would love to hear something like an Ongaku powering a modern horn based system. I'm not including Avant Garde in this as to my ears they sound somewhat different and not as open as the JBL and TAD's I have heard.
Don't get me wrong though. I'd still bite Kevin's arm off for those prototypes - It's an emotional experience to listen to a system of such quality and it's the best I have heard this year by a country mile. I just think I might personally prefer them with a 4003 or 476be in place of the S2 and an ET 703 in place of the 2405.