I thought his comments were a bit naff. My Marantz with its quad DAC and dual output stage and Elna caps trounces an Ipod in terms of sound quality.
I admit though that solid state will always sound better if its lossless and the DAC is the same. Personaly I use all three, lossless, CD and vinyl.
I do think that the CD player is a dying bread, becuase lossless sounds better and so does vinyl so it has made CD obselete.
The entire notion of HIFI is lost anyway, the modern generation of kids are mostly tone deaf.