Always wanted a valve amp?

Dave Simpson said:
Unfortunately, hifi forum audiophiles do seem to have a problem with what others enjoy. Here's one example:

http://www.pinkfishmedia.net/forum/showthread.php?t=94191&page=11

Personally, I need some sort of evidence that there's an acoustical, mechanical or electrical relationship between one entity/adjustment or another before I'll be willing to buy into what's experienced (assuming I even hear a difference) but if some group of folks want to discuss how freezing photographs changed the sound of their rigs and their lives, I'm not going to disrupt their discussion -I simply won't participate.
Click to expand...

LP12 discussions don't count Dave - they break all the rules :D
But yes, I know what you mean.

I do think it important to participate in a discussion if you believe what has been written is clearly inaccurate, mainly because the claims are public and have a potentially large audience. However, just being negative isn't good enough and it must surely be important to present a cogent argument to support your position in such instances.
 
nando said:
every divice has harmonic distortion no matter what specs say, the harmonic distortions also in the human body as most of our organs work in different frequencies, hence the different choice in "prefereable sound" however some hd's can be very confortable where others could be quite irritating, as most of the human organs can find a perfect fulcrom to sound waves others may not,
Click to expand...

Pseudo-scientific new age claptrap of the first water!!! Makes Russ Andrews look like Mr. Spock.

Chris
 
RobHolt said:
LP12 discussions don't count Dave - they break all the rules :D
But yes, I know what you mean.

I do think it important to participate in a discussion if you believe what has been written is clearly inaccurate, mainly because the claims are public and have a potentially large audience. However, just being negative isn't good enough and it must surely be important to present a cogent argument to support your position in such instances.
Click to expand...

Rob,

As I see it, the only problem with expecting proof presented with every claim is the likelyhood something legitimate will get supressed along the way simply because it currently can't be measured or reproduced in every system. Fortunately, for those of us not technically inclined, common sense and experience seems to work just fine. For example, I'm confident a frozen photograph of myself in the freezer will not make a difference in the sound of my hifi without testing it but when I hear slight differences between some main cables in my rig consistently and repeatedly and it's plausible as they are part of the circuit, I'll go with what my ears say vs what an expert tells me.

regards,

dave
 
isn't distortion used as a tool by electronic engineers/ hi fi designers, to tune the sound of their amplifiers? An essentially neutral amp is totally possible, has been produced, but never made it's owners a mint of money, because luckily, we are all different with different tastes and needs. That's part of the fun. SOME people search out equipment that measures 'well', whilst others search out kit that doesn't!
Vive La difference.
 
silverback11 said:
isn't distortion used as a tool by electronic engineers/ hi fi designers, to tune the sound of their amplifiers? An essentially neutral amp is totally possible, has been produced, but never made it's owners a mint of money, because luckily, we are all different with different tastes and needs. That's part of the fun. SOME people search out equipment that measures 'well', whilst others search out kit that doesn't!
Vive La difference.
Click to expand...

It is, but it remains a completely crackers way of tuning a system.
It is incredibly imprecise, wasteful and judging by the number of queries on forums, rarely satisfies. Nor are the mechanisms at work properly understood, and where there is poor understanding there is often error.

Specific equipment exists to manipulate signals in ways which are fully understood, and that manipulation can be as strong or as subtle as you wish.
 
I want to patent a transparent gizmo that adds 'air', 'phatness' and 'niceness' knobs to any hifi.

Unfortuntely Quad et al. got there first.

;)
 

Latest posts

Back
Top