The Devil
IHTFP
What's known for sure is that there is no evidence at all that divining works. That means you are just as likely to find water if you dig at random.
water divining
- Thread starter hifinutt
- Start date
As I say, there is a lot of evidence.....as the opening post suggests.
Beleive whatever you want to beleive guys.
penance
Arrogant Cock
No real evidence tho is it, just some chap who says he find water with a bent welding rod. People say they can hear plants talking....
Cetainly no proof.
Names Andy btw
Cetainly no proof.
Names Andy btw
So, which oil company uses divining to find oil? 'A fact' is usually, you know, factual.
How do you reconcile your claim with the actual fact that every rigorous trial of diviners has shown that they are mistaken?
Paul
What stupid arguement this is.
When I are you going to understand.......I really don't need to!
No real evidence tho is it, just some chap who says he find water with a bent welding rod. People say they can hear plants talking....
Cetainly no proof.
Names Andy btw
Sorry!
Got you mixed up with another.
penance
Arrogant Cock
Sorry david, but why is Pauls argument stupid?
He has reffered to a fact, you have not.
If you want people to take devining seriously then some factual evidence should be put forward. So far all we have is a few people say they believe and therefore it must be true.
The Devil
IHTFP
So, er, still no evidence......
penance
Arrogant Cock
Exactly.
penance
Arrogant Cock
But that is no proof, is he lucky?
Science can not prove everything, many things are still just theory.
There is no evidence to say divining works or that it is worth pursuing in a scientific way, as yet!
As Paul has already said, any scientific scrutiny has shown it to be worthless.
The odds are stacked against it.
Science can not prove everything, many things are still just theory.
There is no evidence to say divining works or that it is worth pursuing in a scientific way, as yet!
As Paul has already said, any scientific scrutiny has shown it to be worthless.
The odds are stacked against it.
The Devil
IHTFP
Not yet, most probably never. But it actually does already have an "answer" to divining.
What next? Ley lines and healing crystals?
Bob McC
living the life of Riley
On here - probably!
It worked for Moses.
Sorta.
Sorta.
A Balanced Response to the Anti-Divining Rhetoric of E.H. Boudreau.
http://www.drilshop.com/holes/bates1.html
Schroter worked alongside professional Hydrogeologists on a variety of groundwater development projects in Sri Lanka, the Philippines, the Dominican Republic, Congo, Niger, Yemen, Cape Verde Islands, Kenya, Namibia, and the Sinai peninsula in Egypt; to locate over 2000 boreholes with project success rates ranging from 80% to 96%....even in these desert areas where the comparable conventional methods achieved success rates of only 10 to 50%.......... Schroter proved to be more successful than the Hydrogeology team by a factor of 4X !
what would be the point for wishing it not to work....?
http://www.drilshop.com/holes/bates1.html
Schroter worked alongside professional Hydrogeologists on a variety of groundwater development projects in Sri Lanka, the Philippines, the Dominican Republic, Congo, Niger, Yemen, Cape Verde Islands, Kenya, Namibia, and the Sinai peninsula in Egypt; to locate over 2000 boreholes with project success rates ranging from 80% to 96%....even in these desert areas where the comparable conventional methods achieved success rates of only 10 to 50%.......... Schroter proved to be more successful than the Hydrogeology team by a factor of 4X !
what would be the point for wishing it not to work....?
Last edited by a moderator:
Interesting article....thanks
"As Paul has already said, any scientific scrutiny has shown it to be worthless."
You haven't posted anything that challenges my assertion.
And one wonders why Herr Schroter hasn't taken Randi for his $1000000.
Paul
And one wonders why Herr Schroter hasn't taken Randi for his $1000000.
Paul
Horses for courses, Paul.
fwiw (I was taught) you shouldn't really dowse for personal gain.
Certainly if you get greedy it interrupts the process.
Herr Schroter would obviously have used the $1000000 for good causes.
Paul
Paul
